Once you've tied off the bag, the next question is what to do with it for the rest of the walk. There's no single right answer — the best holder depends on how you walk, how many dogs you walk, and how much you want to think about it. Here's a fair look at the main categories, with honest pros and cons for each.
We make two of these — a leash loop and a dispenser-plus-loop combo — so we'll point out where each fits as we go. No brand-bashing; just what each type is good at and where it falls short.
The five main types
Clip-on dispensers
- Keep a roll of fresh bags ready on the leash
- Lightweight and widely available
- Simple to attach with a carabiner or snap
- Most hold the roll, not the filled bag — you still carry the knot
- A single filled bag clipped on tends to swing into your legs
- Usually one bag at a time, awkward for multi-dog walks
Pouches
- Contain the bag and any odor away from your clothes
- Can hold more than one filled bag
- Familiar, pocket-like design
- You open and close a pouch with one hand while managing the leash
- Hard to rinse out on a walk if it gets soiled
- Adds bulk that bounces against you as you move
Wristlets
- Keep the bag off your fingers and palm
- Hands stay mostly free for the leash
- Compact and inexpensive
- The bag still rides on your wrist and swings with your arm
- One bag at a time
- Can feel unbalanced on longer walks
Loops that hold the knotted bag
- Bag hangs by its knot, so it stays put instead of swinging
- A well-designed loop holds more than one bag at once
- Nothing to open or close — slot the knot and go
- Fewer options on the market than clips or pouches
- Holds the filled bag, not a fresh roll (unless paired with a dispenser)
Dispenser-plus-loop combos
- Fresh bags and a filled-bag loop in one attachment
- Grab and tear a bag one-handed, then carry it hands-free
- Scales naturally to multi-dog walks
- Slightly more to attach than a bare clip
- A combo is one piece — if you only want the loop, it's more than you need
Where The Hiker and The Walker fit
The Hiker is a plain leash loop — the fourth type above. It attaches to the leash you already own (rope, flat nylon, leather, or webbing) and holds the filled bag by its knot, so the bag stays put instead of swinging. Its triple keyhole slots carry two to three or more bags at once, which is why it suits multi-dog homes and trails. It's $12.99 with free US shipping.
The Walker is a dispenser-plus-loop combo — the fifth type. You get a one-handed bag dispenser and a cargo loop that holds the used bags, all in one attachment. If you like grabbing a fresh bag without letting go of the leash, this is the one. It's $22.99 with free US shipping.
How to choose
If you only ever walk one dog on flat sidewalks and don't mind the occasional swing, a simple clip is fine. If you walk two or more dogs, or you're tired of the bag bouncing against your knee, a loop that holds the knot is the upgrade that actually changes the walk. And if you'd rather not carry a separate roll of bags, a combo keeps everything in one place.
Whichever you pick, the routine stays the same: knot it, slot it, toss it. The holder just decides how much of your walk your hand gets back.